Skip to main content
DemandAxisDemandAxis
Illustrative Case Studies / Managed security services

Illustrative case study | Managed security services

When the buyer already has a provider, the case for change has to be earned

How DemandAxis would build a repeatable route to new business for a small-to-medium UK managed security provider selling into mid-market organisations.

Illustrative scenario. The organisation is hypothetical and no client results are claimed. Market and regulatory facts are sourced at the end.

Mid-market buyersmall IT team, no security leaderIncumbentwins by defaultThe clientmust earn the switchSwitching risk
Client

Founder-led UK MSSP with around 40 staff

Service

24/7 MDR, Microsoft 365 security and Cyber Essentials support

Target buyer

UK organisations with 50 to 500 employees

Starting point

Loyal customers. New business relies on referrals and the founder.

The challenge

Most buyers in this market already have a provider

of medium businesses report outsourcing cyber security to an external provider1

Where deals stall today

OutreachLeads with detection times or analyst headcount
ResponsePolite interest
StallChanging provider feels riskier than living with an adequate service
ResultConversations stall and growth stays reliant on referrals

A stronger capability claim is not always enough to overcome the perceived risk of switching.

Sourced fact
  • Seven in ten medium businesses already outsource cyber security1
  • Cyber Essentials now requires cloud services in scope and MFA where available2
  • The Cyber Security and Resilience Bill is not yet law3
Scenario assumption
  • Delivery quality and retention are strong
  • New business comes mainly through referrals and the founder
  • Most target buyers have no dedicated security leader
Discovery must confirm
  • Why the provider has actually won and lost, from real deals
  • Whether it can onboard several new customers without affecting service
  • Whether a readiness review leads to the core service at a viable margin

The commercial insight

The buyer is paying for the ability to answer three people with confidence.
Buyer

The board

Is cyber risk under control?

The insurer

Which controls are in place?

The largest customer

Searching questions in its supplier questionnaire

The provider that helps answer those questions earns the conversation.

Reasons to act now

Three dated triggers and one recurring moment

Each is used accurately. A buyer who catches one overstated claim will discount everything else.

April 2025

Cyber Governance Code of Practice4

Government guidance setting out what boards and directors should do to govern cyber risk.

52%of medium businesses report board members or trustees with responsibility for cyber security1

Build a board-level argument on assurance, incident readiness and reporting

From April 2026

Cyber Essentials v3.3 (Danzell)2

For new assessments, cloud services can no longer be excluded from scope, and missing MFA where available is an automatic failure.

Prioritise accounts where certification has commercial weight and open with readiness

2 November 2026

Cyber Security and Resilience Bill3, 5

Not yet law

Lords third reading completed. MPs now consider the Lords amendments before Royal Assent. As drafted, it would bring medium and large managed service providers into the NIS regime.

Explain the provider's own readiness before buyers ask

Buyer calendar61%of medium businesses hold some form of cyber cover1

Ask about insurance renewal timing and confirm what each insurer requires

The decision

What first step should the provider offer a buyer who already has one?

Not recommended

A full replacement proposal

Asks the buyer to accept the whole switching risk in the first conversation.

Recommended

A Cyber Essentials readiness review

For accounts where certification matters to customers or insurers. A small, useful piece of work that lets the buyer judge the provider first.

Conditional

Contact timed to the contract end date

Used alongside the review where the end date is known. On its own it leaves most of the market waiting.

Why

The review lowers the cost of saying yes. The buyer sees how the provider works before the larger decision, and the provider learns about the account before proposing.

What would change the recommendation

  • Reviews cannot be delivered profitably, or rarely lead to a conversation about the core service
  • The provider cannot onboard new customers without affecting existing service
  • Certification carries little weight in the chosen segment

Proposed approach

Five steps built around the switching decision

01

Find where the provider wins

Review real wins, losses and departed customers. Confirm onboarding capacity.

OutputICP, exclusions and switching story
02

List accounts by trigger

Each account carries its source and what is still unknown.

OutputResearched account list
03

Make switching feel safe

A low-risk first step and a clear transition plan.

OutputEntry offer and onboarding narrative
04

Argue the case by role

One buying case, written for each decision-maker.

OutputPersona messaging and sequences
05

Qualify and hand over

Against a standard agreed at the start.

OutputQualification criteria and handover template

Decision criteria

A reply becomes an opportunity when these are known

Confirmed triggerIncumbent's contract end dateDecision processPeople involvedAgreed next step
QualifiedAll five are known. Hand over to the provider's sales team.
DiscoveryReal interest, with one or two answers missing. Book the next conversation.
NurtureGood fit, no trigger yet or a contract recently renewed. Revisit at a dated point.
DisqualifyOutside the agreed ICP, or no problem the provider can solve.

An interested reply is a contact, not an opportunity. One missing answer means more discovery, not a lost account.

Who decides

The buying committee

There is often no chief information security officer at this size. The IT manager owns the service day to day but rarely holds the budget.

IT manager or head of IT

Needs to believeThe service reduces out-of-hours burden and noise, the move will not disrupt the business, and they stay in control.
Evidence that moves themTransition plan, escalation process, integration with existing tools, a clear split of responsibilities and sample reports.

Select a person on the map.

StakeholderNeeds to believeEvidence that moves them
Managing director or CEOThe business can show the board, insurers and customers that cyber risk is governed and that an incident would be handled.A plain-English summary of coverage, incident response commitments and board reporting.
Finance directorThe cost is predictable and justified against the current contract and the alternative of building capability in-house.Scope, pricing structure, contract terms and a like-for-like comparison with the incumbent.
IT manager or head of ITThe service reduces out-of-hours burden and noise, the move will not disrupt the business, and they stay in control.Transition plan, escalation process, integration with existing tools, a clear split of responsibilities and sample reports.
Operations or compliance leadCertification and customer questionnaires become easier to pass, and stay that way.A mapping of the service to Cyber Essentials controls and common supplier due-diligence questions.

What we would measure

Meetings with a decision-maker present

Opportunities with a confirmed trigger and known contract end date

Progression between agreed stages

Recorded reasons for stalls and losses

A monthly review feeds the language buyers use back into targeting and messaging, and checks whether the entry offer is leading to core-service conversations.

Illustrative deliverables

ICP and exclusion criteriaSwitching narrative and objection guideTrigger-based account listPersona messaging and sequencesEntry offer and onboarding narrativeQualification standard and handover templateMonthly market feedback review

Every engagement is led by the founder of DemandAxis, who would own research, positioning, outreach and qualification. The provider keeps responsibility for technical accuracy, pricing, delivery and contracts. No meeting volume, pipeline value or revenue outcome is promised.

Find out what would make your best-fit buyers switch.

Book a 30-minute pipeline review